Clearly struggling to come back from his broken ankle and a shadow of his former self.

Do you think TS would consider dropping him?

without a doubt.

At prop I would put both wood and cooper ahead of him at the min (and of course morley and harrison).

I thought he was looking suspect before his injury to be honest... he was dropping alot of ball anyway.

Said on another thread that i have been disappointed with him this season. Wasn't it smith that sold Carvell to Hull?

I thought his best game since coming back from injury was on Saturday night, still got a way to go though I believe.

Don't think Smith will drop him.

Here, here. He needs to be dropped (has to be said). We've just re-signed Cooper for the foreseeable future, yet he doesn't get a game, even though Carvell is well below the level expected of him.
Time for a change, we can't go into games at the crucial part of the season with a passenger. Unfortunately, at the moment, Carvell is a passenger.

Me too

Is a bit hard to get back to top level when you have been out for a few months with a broken leg.

We should drop Monas as he keeps getting knocked dizzy

Slightly unfair to knock him, it takes about 3 months to get back to peak fitness but i'd would give him a bit more time and bring Coops in. Possibly have Gaz on the bench and not a starting prop

Not knocking him, but does not warrant a starting place in front of Paul Wood at the moment

Clarke seems to playing alright. Regarding Carvell, i don't think he was nowhere as good as last season before his injury.

I think it more suits Woody's game to come off the bench

That's what i was thinking, Carvell wouldn't have as much impact as Woody